Indiana Wesleyan captured the 2009 MCC Tournament with 21 points, topping Taylor by three. Both teams entered Saturday tied with 15 points apiece and seven participants in the finals. The Wildcats won four of the five head-to-head matches on their way to the championship.
Taylor won a doubles championship and two singles championships while IWU took home two doubles championships and four singles championships.
Team Points
| Indiana Wesleyan |
21 pts |
| Taylor |
18 pts |
| Marian |
10 pts |
| Grace |
8 pts |
| Huntington |
6 pts |
| Bethel |
0 pts |
| Goshen |
0 pts |
|
Saint Francis |
0 pts |
| Spring Arbor |
0 pts |