| Player | Insititution | Class |
| Ashley Palmer | IN Wesleyan University | Jr |
| Natalie Wiegmann | University of St Francis | Sr |
| Rana Hoffbauer | Marian College | So |
| Raleigh Tillman | IN Wesleyan University | Sr |
| Lisa Franke | Bethel College | Fr |
| Heather Weddle | University of St Francis | So |
| Erin Marcum | IN Wesleyan University | So |
| Kari Wildman | Grace College | So |
| Jessica Hammon | Taylor University | So |
| Andrea Wyatt | University of St Francis | So |
| Jamie Bechdol | Marian College | Sr |
| Megan McKee | University of St Francis | Sr |
| Bethany Keuper | Bethel College | Jr |
| Kristin Morris | IN Wesleyan University | Fr |
| Kara Fultz | Huntington College | So |
| Emily Wallace | Taylor University | Jr |
| Tera Franklin | Goshen College | Sr |
| Gretchen Rayborn | Marian College | Jr |
| Ashley Palmer | IN Wesleyan University | MCC player of the Year |
| John Bratcher | IN Wesleyan University | MCC Coach of the Year |