Bethel
| # | Name | Cl. | Pos. | Ht. | Wt. | Hometown |
| | Drew Bishop | FR | | | | Auburn, IN |
| | Allen Burkett | SO | | | | Warsaw, IN |
| | Raymond Duttweiler | JR | | | | |
| | Harrison Fausey | FR | | | | Columbia City, IN |
| | Bryce Matteson | FR | | | | Mishawaka, IN |
| | Jared Mead | JR | | | | Aurora, IL |
| | Calon Naragon | SR | | | | Mishawaka, IN |
| | Cory Naragon | SO | | | | Mishawaka, IN |
| | Austin O'Conner | FR | | | | North Liberty, IN |
| | Vincent Reel | SR | | | | |
| | Ryan Starkel | SR | | | | Leon, KS |
| | Alex Walsh | FR | | | | Clinton, IN |
| | Ryan Waybright | JR | | | | Fort Wayne, IN |
Ryan Sommers - Head Coach
Honey Storlie - Assistant Coach
Goshen
| # | Name | Cl. | Pos. | Ht. | Wt. | Hometown |
| | Ben Bouwman | JR | | | | Woodridge, IL |
| | Nick Bouwman | JR | | | | Woodridge, IL |
| | Sammy Chege | SR | | | | Nairobi, Kenya |
| | Hugo DeLuna | SR | | | | Goshen, IN |
| | Dietrich Eitzen | JR | | | | Lancaster, PA |
| | Robert Hooley | SO | | | | Bluffton, OH |
| | David Horst | FR | | | | Dalton, OH |
| | Nelson Kling | SR | | | | Ashland, OR |
| | Daniel Merkt-Blatz | SR | | | | San Antonio, TX |
| | Mark Miller | SR | | | | Kalona, IA |
| | Ramadhan Onyango | SR | | | | Nairobi, Kenya |
| | Kris Rath | FR | | | | Mound Ridge, KS |
| | David Rumsey | SR | | | | Iowa City, IA |
| | Jonathan Stuckey | JR | | | | West Unity, OH |
| | Paul Versluis | SO | | | | Ann Arbor, MI |
Doug Yoder - Head Coach
Nick Adkins - Assistant Coach
Mark Furkis - Assistant Coach
Melissa Gillette - Assistant Coach
Lyle Miller - Assistant Coach
Grace
| # | Name | Cl. | Pos. | Ht. | Wt. | Hometown |
| | Matt DeRenzo | FR | | | | |
| | Jacob Hendricks | FR | | | | |
| | Micahel Jennys | SR | | | | |
| | Charles Johnson | JR | | | | |
| | Joshua McGuire | SR | | | | |
| | Philip McGuire | SR | | | | |
| | Daniel Ng | FR | | | | |
| | Samuel Roth | JR | | | | Hudsonville, IN |
| | Zach Schaefer | SO | | | | |
| | Alex Schemmer | SO | | | | |
| | Chad Schmucker | FR | | | | |
| | Sean Smith | FR | | | | |
| | Randy Sterk | FR | | | | |
| | Charles Wheeler | SO | | | | |
Huntington
| # | Name | Cl. | Pos. | Ht. | Wt. | Hometown |
| | Luke Andrews | SR | | | | Franklin, IN |
| | Josh Barnett | SR | | | | Franklin, IN |
| | David Boyer | SO | | | | Fort Wayne, IN |
| | Luke Diehl | JR | | | | Bluffton, IN |
| | Joseph Herber | FR | | | | Fremont, IN |
| | Nick Johnson | SR | | | | Huntington, IN |
| | Dan Lindbloom | SR | | | | Evergreen Park, IL |
| | Joseph Mburu Njeri | JR | | | | Nairobi |
| | Alec Rosario | FR | | | | Valparaiso, IN |
Indiana Wesleyan
| # | Name | Cl. | Pos. | Ht. | Wt. | Hometown |
| | Doug Alles | JR | | | | Ligonier, Ind. |
| | Ben Andrews | FR | | | | Columbus, Ohio |
| | Aaron Bagley | FR | | | | Van Wert, Ohio |
| | Dan Carrick | JR | | | | Cleveland, Ohio |
| | Josh Foss | SR | | | | Marion, Ind. |
| | Bryan Hazel | SR | | | | Bringhurst, Ind. |
| | Rob Klingeman | SR | | | | Allendale, Mich. |
| | Ethan Laudermilch | FR | | | | Binghamton, N.Y. |
| | Joel Liechty | JR | | | | Kendallville, Ind. |
| | Josh Miller | SR | | | | Lima, Ohio |
| | Ethan Naylor | FR | | | | Carrollton, Ohio |
| | Brandon Page | FR | | | | Louisville, Ky. |
| | Dan Roberts | SO | | | | Deton, Mich. |
| | Josh Schweigert | JR | | | | Libertyville, Ill. |
| | Doug Slabaugh | SO | | | | Syracuse, Ind. |
Jon Foss - Head Coach
Lee Smith - Assistant Coach
Marian
| # | Name | Cl. | Pos. | Ht. | Wt. | Hometown |
| | Matt Cummins | SR | | | | Avon, Ind. |
| | Michael Foerster | JR | | | | Ferdinand, Ind. |
| | Derek Harris | FR | | | | Indianapolis, Ind. |
| | Kyle Hinkle | SR | | | | Brownsburg, Ind. |
| | Thomas Jeschke | JR | | | | Indianapolis, Ind. |
| | Corey Kimball | FR | | | | Tell City, Ind. |
| | Kyle Murray | JR | | | | Morgantown, Ind. |
| | Shawn Murray | SR | | | | Morgantown, Ind. |
| | Alan Nordholt | JR | | | | Indianapolis, Ind. |
| | Dean Rothenberger | SO | | | | Mooresville, Ind. |
| | Brant Smith | FR | | | | Greenwood, Ind. |
| | Ryan Strom | JR | | | | Sellersburg, Ind. |
| | James Wangari | SO | | | | Nairobi, Kenya |
| | Michael Wieser | SO | | | | Guilford, Ind. |
Dave Roberts - Head Coach
Vince Corbin - Assistant Coach
Tim Davidson - Assistant Coach
Spring Arbor
| # | Name | Cl. | Pos. | Ht. | Wt. | Hometown |
| | Nathan Martin | FR | | | | Three Rivers, Mich. |
Taylor
| # | Name | Cl. | Pos. | Ht. | Wt. | Hometown |
| | Matt Bane | SO | | | | Merrillville, IN |
| | Isaac Bryan | SO | | | | Perkasie, PA |
| | Braxton Fritz | SR | | | | Middlebury, IN |
| | Tim Griffiths | FR | | | | Wheaton, IL |
| | Jeff Hubley | JR | | | | Northbridge, MA |
| | Chris Leman | SR | | | | Rossville, IN |
| | Michael Pabody | JR | | | | Indianapolis, IN |
| | Tom Robertson | JR | | | | Souderton, PA |
| | Adam Schroer | SO | | | | Bowling Green, IN |
| | Brian Tencher | SO | | | | West Greenwich, RI |