| # | Name | Cl. | Pos. | Ht. | Wt. | Hometown |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Anthony Giovarelli | FR | G | Wauseon, OH | ||
| 2 | Nate Montiel | SR | F | Elkhart, IN | ||
| 3 | Alex Caskey | SO | F | Goshen, IN | ||
| 4 | Ben Martin | JR | D | Goshen, IN | ||
| 5 | Jordan Delp | SO | D | East Greenville, PA | ||
| 6 | Matt Yoder | SR | MF | Elkhart, IN | ||
| 7 | Scott Wilkinson | SO | MF | Harleyville, PA | ||
| 8 | Brennan Troyer | JR | F | Pittsburgh, PA | ||
| 9 | Cody Felton | JR | F | Quakerstown, PA | ||
| 10 | Luke Woodworth | SO | MF | Middlebury, IN | ||
| 11 | Joel Gonzales | SR | MF | Evanston, IL | ||
| 12 | Kyle Stiffney | SO | D | Goshen, IN | ||
| 13 | Rusty Emery | JR | D | Goshen, IN | ||
| 14 | Nick Good | SO | MF | Lititz, PA | ||
| 15 | Tony Janzen | SR | F | Elkhart, IN | ||
| 16 | Benji Graber | SR | D | Goshen, IN | ||
| 17 | David Shenk | JR | MF | Harrisonburg, VA | ||
| 18 | Peter Koonz | SR | MF | Goshen, IN | ||
| 19 | Mark Hershberger | SO | MF | Harrisonburg, VA | ||
| 20 | Juan De Leon | SO | MF | Goshen, IN | ||
| 21 | Brad Graber | SR | D | Sarasota, FL | ||
| 22 | Reuben Stoltzfus | SO | D | Harleysville, PA | ||
| 23 | Garret Osterloo | JR | MF | Elkhart, IN | ||
| 24 | Jesse Heyerly | SO | D | Hubbard, OR |