| | Day | Time | | Opponent | Score | | Record |
| March |
| | 6 | 2:00PM | @ | Lindsey Wilson | L-1-3 | | 0-1 |
| | | Game 2 | @ | Lindsey Wilson | L-2-6 | | 0-2 |
| | 7 | 1:00PM | @ | Hanover College | W-4-3 | | 1-2 |
| | | Game 2 | @ | Hanover College | W-4-0 | | 2-2 |
| | 12 | 3:00PM | @ | Mount Vernon Nazarene | RAIN | | | |
| | | Game 2 | @ | Mount Vernon Nazarene | RAIN | | | |
| | 13 | 3:00PM | vs. | Cedarville University | W-5-0 | | 3-2 |
| | | Game 2 | vs. | Cedarville University | L-4-6 | | 3-3 |
| | 14 | 1:00PM | @ | Indiana University Southeast | L-3-9 | | 3-4 |
| | | Game 2 | @ | Indiana University Southeast | W-4-3 | | 4-4 |
| | 17 | 4:00PM | @ | Purdue University-North Central | L-4-7 | | 4-5 |
| | | Game 2 | @ | Purdue University-North Central | L-2-5 | | 4-6 |
| * | 19 | 3:00PM | @ | Goshen | L-1-4 | | 4-7 0-1 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Goshen | W-14-8 | | 5-7 1-1 |
| | 21 | 9:00AM | vs. | Trinity Christian College | W-11-7 | | 6-7 |
| | Tucson Invitational Games |
| | | 1:30PM | vs. | Missouri Valley College | L-4-8 | | 6-8 |
| | 23 | 11:00AM | vs. | St. Olaf College | W-10-2 (5) | | 7-8 |
| | | 1:00PM | vs. | Buena Vista University | W-9-1 (6) | | 8-8 |
| | 24 | 1:00PM | vs. | North Central College | W-7-4 | | 9-8 |
| | | 3:00PM | vs. | St. Olaf College | W-8-0 (5) | | 10-8 |
| | 25 | 9:00AM | vs. | Gustavus Adolphus | L-2-4 | | 10-9 |
| | | 11:00AM | vs. | Luther College | L-0-12 (5) | | 10-10 |
| | 26 | 9:00AM | vs. | Calvin College | L-2-9 | | 10-11 |
| | | 11:00AM | vs. | St. Catherine University | W-8-6 | | 11-11 |
| April |
| * | 2 | 3:00PM | vs. | Bethel | L-2-5 | | 11-12 1-2 |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Bethel | L-0-5 | | 11-13 1-3 |
| * | 4 | 1:00PM | @ | Saint Francis | W-8-2 | | 12-13 2-3 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Saint Francis | L-4-5 | | 12-14 2-4 |
| | USF scores 2 in bottom of 7th for 1st MCC win |
| | 7 | 3:00PM | vs. | Saint Joseph's College | RAIN | | | |
| | | Game 2 | vs. | Saint Joseph's College | RAIN | | | |
| * | 9 | 3:00PM | @ | Grace | W-7-1 | | 13-14 3-4 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Grace | L-1-2 (8) | | 13-15 3-5 |
| * | 11 | 11:00AM | vs. | Spring Arbor | L-4-6 | | 13-16 3-6 |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Spring Arbor | L-2-6 (9) | | 13-17 3-7 |
| * | 16 | 4:00PM | @ | Huntington | L-0-1 | | 13-18 3-8 |
| | Game moved from Taylor to Huntington |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Huntington | L-5-6 | | 13-19 3-9 |
| * | 22 | 3:00PM | @ | Marian | L-1-4 | | 13-20 3-10 |
| | Rescheduled from 4-21-09 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Marian | L-0-6 | | 13-21 3-11 |
| * | 23 | 3:00PM | vs. | Indiana Wesleyan | W-6-0 | | 14-21 4-11 |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Indiana Wesleyan | L-0-8 (5) | | 14-22 4-12 |
| | Live Stats |
| | 25 | 1:00PM | vs. | St. Mary-of-the-Woods College | W-4-3 | | 15-22 |
| | | Game 2 | vs. | St. Mary-of-the-Woods College | W-6-5 | | 16-22 |
| | Live Stats |
| | 28 | 10:00AM | vs. | Marian | L-3-4 (8) | | 16-23 |
| | MCC Tournament - Marion, Ind. |
| | 29 | 5:00PM | vs. | Saint Francis | W-5-4 (8) | | 17-23 |
| | MCC Tournament - Marion, Ind. Live Stats |
| | | 10:00PM | vs. | Indiana Wesleyan | W-1-0 | | 18-23 |
| | MCC Tournament |